BESS preliminary design: from a power at the point of connection to a checked single-line diagram

The first questions about a battery storage project come long before detailed engineering. A developer has an agreed power at the point of connection and a power factor from the grid code, and needs to know how many power conversion systems (PCS) of which size, what transformer, which cables, and whether the plant will still meet the reactive power requirement when the grid voltage is low. The answers decide the offer.

The BESS Preliminary Design study in Electrisim takes that short list of inputs, draws the plant, runs the load flows and reports what fits and what does not. This guide walks through it.

Start from the point of connection

Two numbers define the job: the active power Pn at the point of connection (POC) and the power factor the grid code asks for. The required reactive power follows from them:

Q = Pn · tan(arccos(PF))

For 50 MW and a power factor of 0.95 this is 16.4 Mvar, or 0.329 of Pn, in both directions, while charging and while discharging, and at the lowest and the highest grid voltage.

Why the PCS must be larger than the plant power

A converter has an apparent power rating. At full active power the reactive power it has left is √(Sn2 − P2), so a PCS rated exactly at its active power has none. Three more things eat into the margin:

  • Losses and auxiliaries. Transformers, cables and the auxiliary load take active power, so the converters must deliver more than Pn for Pn to arrive at the POC.
  • Transformer reactive power. Every transformer absorbs reactive power, roughly its short-circuit voltage times the square of its loading. The converters have to cover it before any reaches the grid.
  • Low voltage. A converter is limited by current. At 0.95 p.u. it delivers 5 % less apparent power than at rated voltage.

This is why the auto-sizer in the study proposes, for the 50 MW example with four units, about 21.3 MVA per PCS with an active power limit of 14.85 MW each. The four units could carry 59 MW by their active power limit, and their apparent power is 85 MVA. The difference is what pays for the reactive power at the POC.

The plant the wizard draws

Topology of the BESS plant: external grid, point of connection, HV/MV transformer with tap changer, MV collection bus with auxiliary load, and strings of MV cable, MV/LV transformer, PCS and battery Grid POC HV/MV, OLTC MV bus Auxiliary load MV cable MV/LV PCS Battery (DC) one of N strings
Plant topology. An HV cable between the POC and the plant substation, and a three-winding string transformer with two or four PCS per winding, are optional.

From the inputs the wizard generates the single-line diagram: the external grid, the POC bus, the HV/MV transformer with its on-load tap changer, the MV collection bus with the auxiliary load, and one string per PCS with its MV cable, MV/LV transformer, converter, DC bus and battery rack. For a connection at medium voltage, about 11 to 33 kV, the HV/MV transformer is left out.

Ratings are sized automatically until you type one in. A rating you enter is kept exactly as entered, and a note tells you when it is below what the auto-sizer would have chosen. The note is a pointer and not a verdict, because the auto-sizer keeps some margin. The load flows decide.

What the study checks

CheckWhat it tells you
18 named load-flow casesExport and import at full power, capacitive and inductive, at the lowest, the nominal and the highest grid voltage, plus rated charge and discharge at unity power factor. Each case passes or fails on loading and voltage, and names the element that limits it.
Rating tableThe worst loading of every PCS, transformer and cable against its nameplate.
P/Q envelope at the POCThe reactive power the plant can deliver and absorb from full charge to full discharge, against the rectangle the power factor requires.
U-Q at full powerThe same at rated charge and rated discharge over the voltage range. Both directions must cover the band for a compliant verdict.
Tap position sweep (optional)How the tap changer of the HV/MV transformer moves the internal voltages and the available reactive power.

Clicking a case or a point on a chart puts that load flow on the diagram, so you can see the voltages and loadings behind a failed case. The results can be exported as a PDF summary.

How to run it

  1. Open a blank diagram, or the Utility-scale BESS (HV POC) template.
  2. Click Simulate → BESS Studies → BESS Preliminary Design.
  3. Enter the active power at the POC and the grid-code power factor. Set the voltage levels, the number of PCS and the topology.
  4. Click Generate / Update SLD and look at the diagram.
  5. Click Run Study and review the cases, the rating table and the two charts.

Reading a result that surprises you

  • A case passes but delivers less than Pn. Pass and fail are about loading and voltage only. Whether the requested P and Q reached the POC is a separate figure in the results.
  • A few Mvar remain at full power although the converters are at their limit. That is the reactive power of the transformers and cables. The battery cannot supply it. Either rate the PCS above its active power limit, or accept slightly less active power.
  • Every case fails on PCS apparent power. Look for a typed PCS rating that is smaller than its active power limit, and use Reset ratings to auto-size.
  • Cases pass on power but fail on loading. The limiting element is named in the table. It is often an MV cable.

What it does not replace

This is a load-flow study for the early design. It does not replace short-circuit, protection or dynamic studies, and the DC side is drawn but not solved. Use it to arrive at a configuration that is worth engineering in detail.

The study is under Simulate → BESS Studies at app.electrisim.com.

Related: BESS studies in the documentation, the video walkthrough, BESS sizing for busbar targets and the grid code compliance study for the full P-Q and U-Q diagrams.

Try Electrisim Personal for $10 per month

Run pandapower, OpenDSS & ANDES studies (load flow, short-circuit, OPF, harmonics, dynamics) in your browser — cancel anytime, no setup fees.

Subscribe Secure via Stripe · 1-click cancel